- New York Times
" A bawdy, ridiculous, unauthorized parody of the show"
- New York Times
"Bayside! The Musical! will have you rolling in the aisles" - OK! Magazine
"Bayside! The Musical!, is the new giant-cell phone on the block of New York's theater scene."
- Maxim Magazine
"A hell of a lot of ribald fun."
- The New York Times
"Saved By The Bell meets Book of Mormon."
- Julie Chang, FOX 5
"Like Saved By The Bell, but with more jokes about spanking it."
"Bayside Provides Silliness and Raunch"
- Broadway World
"Bayside gives the squeky-clean Saturday morning television show a campy, hilarious makeover!"
"Bayside!” serves up snappy songs, double entendres, and creepy sexuality... plus a bevy of inside jokes for the “Saved” superfans”
"Hilarious and often spot-on”
- Broke Ass Stuart
"Highbrow brilliant... This is the Saved by the Bell we've been waiting for."
- Forces of Geek
"Bayside! The Musical! is hammy kitsch at its schmaltziest”
- Theater Pizzazz
"Go see Bayside! The Musical! Today. Not tomorrow, but right this instant."
- Broke Bored and Lazy
- Clyde Fitch Report
"From what we can tell, this musical has everything: song numbers about homoerotic wrestling, brick-sized cellphones, teenage pregnancy and all of the tropicalia patterns you could hope for worn by one Samuel "Screech" Powers."
"It's comical AND genius."
- Talent in Motion
"Get ready to flash back to the early '90s, with zig-zag patterns, pastel and neon colors, and big... cell phones.
"I can’t imagine anyone who loves the 90s not having a great time at this show."
- Adam's World
"It was AMAZING!"
- Queer Fat Femme Guide to the Net
"The best two hours of the year you can spend with some friends”
- Latino Sports
"We definitely think Slater was gay!"